Which will happen every time, with every thread, on almost any topic. You don't just see it with sim vs sim, you see it with those who think a sim has the right grip, or too little, can accept the gfx level, or can't. It's the same argument in every thread, a few words changed here and there, but the same obsessive reluctance to go and enjoy themselves with what they do have and like, or to accept than someone else likes and enjoys something they don't. It's not just an issue in simracing, for sure, it's an issue with Apple and Microsoft, XBOX and PlayStation, everything. It's something I'm getting tired of, but I know nobody can really do much about it, so I let threads like this happen, let them waste their own personal time having the same endless points thrown in either direction, then when someone finally snaps, I close it. I'm bored of it, but there's not much else can be done. For you, as an end user, the best position you have is to find a favorite sim (which it sounds you have right now), and use it. Dabble in others, see how they emerge (especially the evolving ones like rF2, iRacing, AC, pCARS) over time, and jump ship whenever you have a new favorite. Simracing is spoiled these days, there are a LOT of choices that I never felt I had, I guess I too don't really understand why people find it impossible to make a choice, and enjoy themselves. They'd much rather spend hours on a forum repeating themselves opposite someone who is NEVER going to change their mind for the same reason the other side won't. Perhaps if they spent that time actually running a sim they have negative feelings about, they'd change their viewpoint on it without having to listen to anyone.