I've seen this said around the various different social platforms and it's starting to bother me because I feel like it's riling people up more based on a narrative that is fundamentally untrue. I have no idea whether this narrative was crafted in bad faith or there's a sincere misunderstanding as I don't expect rF2 players to understand the inner workings of the iRacing community. And yes, that is me, I'm from that community.
Hello, it's Lizard, your friendly neighborhood iRacer. I'm saying this to admit that I have a bias but I'm here in good faith because I'm joining an rF2 IndyCar league and giving this sim a sincere shake. In fact, I bought rF2 back in 2013... only decided to reinstall early this month before this maelstrom kicked off so I'm doing my best to post in good faith and engage with you rF2 players.
You are going to run across pretentious and entitled iRacers who feel that the official name of every motorsports should be attached to their platform. These people exist, I do not deny that. But these are an incredibly tiny group of people to the point where they are the equivalent of maybe just a handful of troll accounts.
The vast majority of iRacers are upset not because they don't get to call their events the official events of Le Mans or IndyCar or whatever, it's because these exclusive deals stop iRacing from putting on events that are similar in nature to these events that MSG has signed and given to rF2. As someone that is embedded in the iRacing community and is in a big iRacing team, the vast majority of reactions to news of exclusivity against iRacing is "ok, who cares if we don't get to call it the "official" Le Mans or IndyCar". But then iRacing quickly updates their internal policies where events that are hosted by them have to fully stop. This is what iRacers are upset about. It's not that they can't call their version of the 24 hours of Le Mans the official name, it's because iRacing can't put on those events at all anymore because these exclusivity deals have a clause that says iRacing can't put on events officially (meaning either in their competitive system or as a big special event) for their own community, that are "similar in nature" to the series and events that have been signed away from them.
That's why iRacing hasn't had an official "The France 24 Hours" or whatever. Because they can't put on a race officially in any capacity. Sure, individual leagues can still put on a 24 Hour race at the Le Mans track and even still call it Le Mans because it's a private event. But most iRacers play the game to practice and run their official events so for a vast majority of the player base, it's one big event that's near and dear to sim racers that won't be run in an official server capacity. Not to mention this disappears from their CS.
The recent IndyCar deal was much worse and goes a step further. Not only has the Indy 500 been removed from iRacing's official special events calendar, but iRacing cannot put official races of the IR18, DW12, or IR05 on tracks that host an IndyCar race. This is the "likeness" clause of the exclusivity deal written in an even more strict capacity and this has caused the community, who have loved to run official server races with the IR18 at Laguna Seca, Watkins Glen, and most if the iRacing ovals, to forcibly abandon their favorite car on their favorite tracks.
This deal has also reached into the private community section as well, as the IR18, DW12, and IR05 are banned by iRacing from being broadcasted by private leagues. Why do you think I've decided to reinstall rF2? Because all my iRacing IndyCar leagues that I've run for the past 2-3 years have now shut down because of the news. Because iRacing said they will enforce the clause against them that iRacing cannot "represent IndyCar in any similar capacity". Here is a screenshot from an iRacing broadcasting discord:
The last point and this one is a more abstract one. The exclusivity deals lock iRacing from building content of the series that have signed away from them. iRacing have historically had a hard time getting access to cars and tracks that they don't have a deal with the official series. I don't know why that is, there's a lot of speculation around that. But iRacing had plans to return to Le Mans and get the Bugatti circuit for their game, that's scrapped because of the deal. iRacing is quite literally not welcomed according to the ACO. IndyCar is a similar story, iRacing has spent a long time trying to negotiate access to street courses such as St. Pete for their game. With the recent IndyCar license, that is now no longer a possibility.
You can even see it in the Automobilista 2 forums that the exclusivity deal that MSG has signed has actually made AMS2 cancel their "fictional" version of the IR18. AMS2 wasn't even going to call it the IR18 or the IndyCar and yet MSG has stepped in and forced them to shelve that project.
This does not mean that I excuse my fellow iRacer's behavior towards rF2 players. And you can still believe after all this that iRacers are babies.
But what I do hope to demonstrate is that the feeling that people have from that community (and to a lesser extent AMS2's community) is not over merely just "what they get to call their events". It quite literally dictates and effects what iRacing players can't run in their official servers and, with the case of IndyCar, what private leagues can't do with the IR18, DW12, or IR05 and IndyCar tracks. Just writing this out already makes me a little mad internally, but my only motivation with this post is to outline the situation fully and dispel incorrect rumors or narratives of why our communities have this infighting.
It's not just over what other sims get to call their special events. If it was only down to naming and branding, and nothing else changed. Quite literally the vast majority of people on that side wouldn't care.